Plaintiff in A lawsuit seeking to overturn President Joe Biden’s student debt forgiveness program is a beneficiary of debt forgiveness in the form of a Paycheck Protection Program business loan worth more than double the maximum amount covered by Biden’s program. did.
Myra Brown, one of two plaintiffs in the Texas lawsuit, owns Desert Star Enterprises Inc. Desert Star is believed to be a sign manufacturer and received a loan of $48,000, of which she received a loan of $47,996. allowed By comparison, Biden’s Student Debt Relief Program offers relief of up to $20,000 if the person seeking relief received a federal Pell Grant, and $10,000 if not. Brown alleges that she is harmed by Biden’s debt relief order because her student loans were originally funded by private companies, so she is not eligible for them.
Brown’s case is one of the breakout cases. right-wing litigation It aims to end Biden’s student debt forgiveness program. Many have been fired for lack of status, but not this one. U.S. District Judge Mark T. Pittman, appointed by Donald Trump for the Northern District of Texas, said he wanted to pursue it quickly.
Student debt relief advocates say the lawsuit is an artificial turf effort by a right-wing political organization. Braxton Brewington, spokesman for Debt Collective, told The Intercept, “These bogus lawsuits are blatantly fabricated by billionaire-funded right-wing organizations whose purpose is to engage in dirty politics. “These plaintiffs aren’t really harmed by the cancellation of student debt. They’re dark money who will do anything to prevent working people from having a financial break.” It’s just willing to be the group’s political pawn.”
When The Intercept reached out to Brown for comment, she replied via text message, attaching a photo of a printout that read, “No Comments,” the conservative advocacy group funding the lawsuit. I directed the inquiry to the Job Creators Network, which was founded by the CEO of Home Depot and funded by the conservative Mercer Family Foundation.
“The Paycheck Protection Program is no match for Biden’s bailout,” Job Creators Network president Elaine Parker told The Intercept. “Congress passed PPP and made it a legal program. Biden bypassed Congress and made it illegal. PPP was an emergency measure to help small businesses survive government-imposed lockdowns. PPP has always been designed to be acceptable if certain parameters are met.”
The Intercept soon received an email from TJ Winner, who claimed to be an employee of the Job Creators Network Foundation, from an email address with the domain name CRC Advisors, a crisis communications firm. The CRC’s largest funder is the Federalist Society. The Federalist Society is a powerful conservative legal group with all six conservative Supreme Court justices as members. Pittman, the federal judge presiding over the case, himself a vice president, founder of the Tarrant County Federalist Association.
In 2019, the CRC came under fire over its attempt to clear then-Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh over sexual misconduct allegations by Kristin Blasey Ford. Working with conservative legal activist Ed Whelan, Doppelganger Blasey Ford mistook him for Kavanaugh. Whelan retracted his allegations and apologized for what he called a “horrifying and inexcusable error of judgment.”
Student debt relief advocates have criticized the hypocrisy of business owners who are happy with their companies’ debt relief but not with student debt relief. Like the Republican congressman who took out a PPP loan while blaming the borrower, Myra Brown believes in ‘debt relief for me, not you,'” Brewington told The Intercept. “This hypocrisy only underscores the cynical motives of the plaintiffs and the baselessness of their case to be dismissed.”
In August, Biden swipe Georgia Congressman Marjorie Taylor Green said: Anyway, that woman who believes inLater the official Twitter account of the White House called out Greene’s name reveals that the figure was actually a little higher, and a $183,504 PPP loan was forgiven.
Brewington also asked Biden to exercise additional powers to block these types of lawsuits. “Instead of allowing student debt relief to be overturned by these unscrupulous actors and Trump-appointed judges, President Biden will use his powers of compromise and settlement to cancel student debt, He should thereby withdraw the rug under these bogus lawsuits and fulfill his promise,” he said.
Pittman is one of 200 federal judges appointed by Trump, and the group includes about as many appeals court judges as Barack Obama appointed in both terms. . Given Pittman’s right-wing affiliation, student debt relief advocates fear his conservative tendencies could lead to support for litigation. Repealed a Texas law prohibiting anyone under the age of 21 from carrying a handgun, citing “history and tradition.”